You have to login first in order to be able to post messages.
Click here to login or register if you are a new user.

Photoshop or Illustrator?

Pinkpapertini
I have Adobe Creative Suite that I would like to begin learning how to use. I would like to learn how to create things such as the attached image. Would I begin with Photoshop or Illustrator to create things like this? Or is it something totally different?

Thanks so much for your input!



Idea
Posted: 11/11/2011, 06:49:37 AM
Embe2006
Illustrator is what you want to use for this.



Good luck!



Adobe products, Wacom Cintiq 21ux, Apple products
Posted: 11/11/2011, 14:51:42 PM
TMarchev
I work with Photoshop(for rasters) and Illustrator(for vectors)... two programs are good :)



That image is product of AI & PS :)))



 Modern web template 
Edited: 11/12/2011, 01:35:00 AM
Artalis
Do any of you use photoshop as a primary tool, combining photographs and drawn work and all the tools of Ps including the clone,brush,filters etc for your work here at dreamstime.?



If so how do you handle issues to do with interpolation and filters?



Thanks

Artalis
Canon 7D from August 2012
Posted: 12/04/2011, 15:52:22 PM
Nongpimmy
like the picture in your post i would go with illustrator

photoshop use for editing the picture like realistic
illustrator use for making cartoons,icons,patterns,etc.

enjoy!
Nikon D3100
Posted: 03/09/2012, 23:53:56 PM
Julesunlimited
Illustrator it is. Output of text in Ps is horrible.
Try it: Type a few words in Ps and zoom in to 100%. Look at the edges of the letters (especially at curves). Do the same with Illustrator (make it, save it and open it in photoshop and zoom in to 100%). As you can see the edges of the words in Illustrator are sharp, while the letters in Ps....

The attached file is a perfect Illustrator example.
Illustrator
Posted: 03/18/2012, 22:30:57 PM
Rolmat
member is an admin

Originally posted by Julesunlimited:
Quoted Message: Illustrator it is. Output of text in Ps is horrible. Try it: Type a few words in Ps and zoom in to 100%. Look at the edges of the letters (especially at curves). Do the same with Illustrator (make it, save it and open it in photoshop and zoom in to 100%). As you can see the edges of the words in Illustrator are sharp, while the letters in Ps....The attached file is a perfect Illustrator example.


Julesunlimited,

That's not exactly true. In fact, it all depends on how your workflow on PS is to produce acceptable lettering. First of all, remember that as any other elements, text are also bitmaps and not vectors, and any over-processing can leads to awkard results. Here are some basic tips:

- Always leave the lettering to the final stages of your work, instead of beginning with it on large sized artworks. See, when you reduce the whole composition, lettering will be seriously affected (specially if already rasterized). On the contrary, Illustrator deals with lettering as vectors, so resizing won't affect the final result.

- Finally, before rasterizing your lettering on PS, select the Type Tool and type something. Then, use the top drop menu with the following options "None, Sharp, Crisp, Strong & Smooth" and select the best option for your text in order to avoid the mentioned awkward results. Test yourself.

CHECK HERE

- Then rasterize everything and save at the highest quality.

Hope it helps.
Edited: 04/03/2012, 20:28:28 PM by Admin
Artistashmita
member is an admin
i think a fusion is usually required at some point in learning phase, you would need to learn both in the long run, although you can start with any, if you go with photoshop, you would learn a bit of illustrator with shape drawing and vector masks.., and if illustrator, then raster effects will make you learn a bit of PS
D7000 (various lenses), E5 Render farm.
Posted: 04/04/2012, 06:47:46 AM
Celiaak
I would do that kind of illustration in a vector program like illustrator (or inkscape, in my case). That way you can sell vector files too.
Nikon D3100, Inkscape, Imagination, Hands
Edited: 04/09/2012, 15:13:41 PM
Gheburaseye
inkscape, but I'm always open to try other software ;)
Inkscape, gimp and other softwares
Posted: 04/22/2012, 11:39:38 AM
Hugeusd
Get Adobe Illustrator CS6. It's awesome
Learn,learn and learn then create and sale

Good luck
Adobe Illustrator CS6
Posted: 05/20/2012, 13:59:26 PM
Fengai
I draw my illustrations Photoshop

I like the idle work and fun,
buy a photographic raster bitmap images, and then go out of style!
Photoshop can do everything!
Edited: 05/20/2012, 14:57:08 PM
Nancyfromafrica
i have never been able to learn illustrator i am good at photoshop
pictures....
Posted: 10/04/2012, 06:20:52 AM
Gheburaseye
inkscape is the same of illustrator and it's open source ;)
Inkscape, gimp and other softwares
Posted: 10/04/2012, 06:38:44 AM
Therealdarla
Inkscape is NOT the same. It is a vector handling program, but has different features.
Nikon D70, standard lens
Posted: 10/04/2012, 09:21:25 AM
Justfenix

Originally posted by Fengai:
Quoted Message: I draw my illustrations PhotoshopI like the idle work and fun, buy a photographic raster bitmap images, and then go out of style!Photoshop can do everything!


Tell the Sign Maker or Silkscreener that when they need to increase your 6" tall raster format illustration to 18" or take one of your absolutely adorable ponies and blow it up to 4' tall to be incorporated into a vehicle wrap.

Photoshop is a fun and extremely useful tool that enables many things, but it does not do everything.

If you are drawing for yourself and just for fun, you are probably fine staying with Photoshop but sine you are here on this site, I assume you want to have some commercial success as well. Start playing with Illustrator. It has a larger learning curve than Photoshop but it drastically expands the commercial market for your work.
Posted: 10/31/2012, 14:28:44 PM
Gheburaseye

Originally posted by Therealdarla:
Quoted Message: Inkscape is NOT the same. It is a vector handling program, but has different features.

True, but I'm an illustrator designer, and I ca tell You that is not a software that make my images, but me. Starting from this point of view, inkscape is the same of illustrator ;)
Inkscape, gimp and other softwares
Posted: 11/01/2012, 11:57:30 AM