community of royalty free images and stock photography
Language: EN DE ES FR IT NL PT
Login Password
Forgot your password? | Not a member?

photography
illustrations
only vector/RAW
Match all words Match any word | Reset search
RF
editorial
exclusive
with people
new search 
memorize options
| Content filter on off
Dreamfinder - advanced serch

 

Home > Dreamstime Message Board > Positive criticism > Opinions on this shot please

 

You have to login first in order to be able to post messages.
Click here to login or register if you are a new user.

 

Page:
1
  
 of 2
Showing posts 1 - 20 of 24

Opinions on this shot please

Author Message
Toddsm66
10 posts
Message edited at 10/21/2004, 13:44:37 PM by Toddsm66
I've had an idea kicking around for a while to do a series of film noir style shots, but doing them in color. I'm a huge fan of the old 50's film noir movies, so I have a lot of good ideas for this series planned out.

A lot of the shots I want to do will require somebody to model for me, but I also picked up an old mannequin head off of ebay to play around with. Here is my first shot from this series using that mannequin head:

Noir
  

I'd love to get some opinions on this shot. I was trying to light this so it wasn't completely obvious that this was a big, fake, plastic head. Not sure if I pulled it off or not.
Canon EOS D60 Canon Powershot G2 Canon EOS Elan 7e Canon ...

Uploaded files: 0 | Total Sales: 0
Ericsphotos
285 posts
Message posted at 10/21/2004, 11:53:37 AM by Ericsphotos
I like the shot but if I did it I would spot light his chin or mouth instead of his neck. I understand that you couldn't do it because it is a mannequin. Also different engle would be more dramatic.
Canon EOS 10D, several Canon and Sigma lenses. Epson Perfect...

Uploaded files: 0 | Total Sales: 209
Achilles
3811 posts
78
Message edited at 10/21/2004, 11:58:41 AM by Achilles - member is an admin
I think the composition and lighting is perfect. The expression that the manequin has seems also perfect, like it was designed for this shot. Not all models can be that expressive.
The only thing that isn't good is that is visible non-human. First I thought it was computer generated, that would have been easier to fix. The skin lacks human imperfections, scratches and dots...

PS: perhaps the hat has a little strange position? like is on a closer plane in the foreground, maybe including more of it would help, while it will also move the head deeper within background. just a thought.
Nikon D300 / Nikon N80 | Nikon 10.5mm f/2.8G ED AF DX Fishey...

Uploaded files: 2336 | Total Sales: 15199
Webking
362 posts
Message edited at 10/21/2004, 12:07:14 PM by Webking
Great Concept.

It appears a little dark, but this might be just on my monitor (LCD). Like Ericphoto said maybe spot the chin. Use color gels to highlight different areas.

Because it is a Mannequin, black and white, sepia or other tones may mask that fact. Also playing around with different color gels may add more drama to the scene.

But the idea and what I see so far looks great. I look forward to seeing the end results.



Nikon D2X, Nikon D200, Nikon 18-2-- VR, Tamron 180mm Mac...

Uploaded files: 5328 | Total Sales: 37801
Toddsm66
10 posts
Message posted at 10/21/2004, 13:14:02 PM by Toddsm66
Thanks for the great tips...I will have to keep experimenting on this one.
Canon EOS D60 Canon Powershot G2 Canon EOS Elan 7e Canon ...

Uploaded files: 0 | Total Sales: 0
Fotoeye75
426 posts
<10
Message posted at 10/21/2004, 14:04:27 PM by Fotoeye75
great idea .. I have a book around here somewhere on 50's hollywood portraiture. I'll dig it out later tonight and flip through to see what tips it might have in it for you. I do know that all the lighting back then was extreme hot lamps, usually the same ones used in cinematography, so you might wanna get some hot lights from a hardware store if you dont have any already ... and do a lot of spot metering :)
Nikon Nikon Nikon .... & a bunch of stuff from Photogenic

Uploaded files: 2337 | Total Sales: 6080
Tomazl
124 posts
Message posted at 10/26/2004, 10:12:48 AM by Tomazl
The idea is great. Work on it. This photo is too dark for me. Try also to isolate the mannequin on white background.
Eos 10D, Eos 20D, EF 17-40 f4, EF 85 f1.8, Sigma EX 105 f2.8...

Uploaded files: 0 | Total Sales: 251
Razvanjp
151 posts
73
Message posted at 10/26/2004, 11:26:03 AM by Razvanjp
The idea is great.I think although that the left part is too dark.A bit more soft those darkness part of the image should be better.And maybe in the next shot for this image will you use a human model.In this form I see this image on the cover on a CD game.Anyway super idea.
Bodies:
Canon EOS 5D Mark II (from March 20...


Uploaded files: 4965 | Total Sales: 13794
Bevd@l
12 posts
Message posted at 10/26/2004, 12:31:26 PM by Bevd@l
Shadowed face is typical for the old 50's movies. Another typical element that might help in this case is the intensive back light /you can use also color light/. This will give you the column shadows on the oval surfaces.
Canon 30d, Sony Cyber-Shot P52, Minolta RIVA100

Uploaded files: 53 | Total Sales: 706
Leaf
33 posts
80
Message posted at 11/09/2004, 12:19:18 PM by Leaf
yeah, i like the shot quite a bit actually.. i think the idea of using a manequin is great.....
Canon 5D mark II + some glass

Uploaded files: 5217 | Total Sales: 12758
Photodesign
144 posts
69
Message posted at 11/10/2004, 05:12:27 AM by Photodesign - member is an admin
I have a single one notice .. i think the image is too much on center... just try a new one with the left shoulder. I think the image it will be more powerfull and give to image an exact direction to look.
Anyway, i like verry much this shot... it is a wonderful ideea.
Medium format:

Mamiya RB67 Profesional
- Ma...


Uploaded files: 4519 | Total Sales: 9046
Toddsm66
10 posts
Message posted at 11/10/2004, 13:31:21 PM by Toddsm66
Thanks for all the input...Definitely helping me out.

Here is the second in my Noir series:

  

Private Eye

Once again, I didnt have anybody handy to model for me in this shot, so the ole mannequin head was put into use once again. An odd contraption with the head mounted on top of a vaccuum cleaner and floor-stand fan, wrapped in a trenchcoat. Here is what this looked like from the other side, without the trenchcoat:

  

Not very pretty, but I think it actually worked out quite well.
Canon EOS D60 Canon Powershot G2 Canon EOS Elan 7e Canon ...

Uploaded files: 0 | Total Sales: 0
Achilles
3811 posts
78
Message posted at 11/10/2004, 15:32:39 PM by Achilles - member is an admin
Hey Todd, I saw your file one hour earlier and wanted to send you a comment. I wouldn't have thought about such setup, I knew you are using the manequin but the sillhouete seems so real, I could bet the trenchcoat is real. A fan? How did that come up?

I can't make any suggestions, the files seems perfect, with enough free space for copy, for those that really need it. The most subtle thing is that the letters are mirrored, looks like the viewer is inside the detective's room, which adds interactivity to the scene. Knock, knock....

Well done!
Nikon D300 / Nikon N80 | Nikon 10.5mm f/2.8G ED AF DX Fishey...

Uploaded files: 2336 | Total Sales: 15199
Toddsm66
10 posts
Message posted at 11/10/2004, 17:02:25 PM by Toddsm66
Thanks!

The fan gave a little bit of width to the "body". With just the head on the vacuum, the trenchcoat didn't wrap around very well, and it just looked like a head on a pole. The top of the fan worked as the shoulders for the coat to set on. I was basically just grabbing anything within reach trying to rig this up, I was really surprised when I went around to the other side of the door and saw how it looked.
Canon EOS D60 Canon Powershot G2 Canon EOS Elan 7e Canon ...

Uploaded files: 0 | Total Sales: 0
Janescape
81 posts
64
Message posted at 11/10/2004, 19:36:00 PM by Janescape
Toddsm66, you are very creative. You have given me some ideas :)
Canon 50D Lenses: 28-135mm IM, 100-400mm IM

Uploaded files: 63 | Total Sales: 464
Pixel-pizzazz
190 posts
<10
Message posted at 11/10/2004, 21:49:17 PM by Pixel-pizzazz
VERY cool! They say 'necessity is the Mother of invention' - how true - good for you!

Very convincing! (the PI guy that moonlights as the vacuum guy - he finds all the dirt - :) :) )


Uploaded files: 190 | Total Sales: 3952
Webking
362 posts
Message posted at 11/10/2004, 22:59:38 PM by Webking
It looks great.

Lighting looks right on, and it has that retro look for the era you are shooting for.

Good job.
Nikon D2X, Nikon D200, Nikon 18-2-- VR, Tamron 180mm Mac...

Uploaded files: 5328 | Total Sales: 37801
Pixel-pizzazz
190 posts
<10
Message posted at 11/11/2004, 22:01:31 PM by Pixel-pizzazz
did you beautify the door front too in PS or is it the nice brown wood on the front?


Uploaded files: 190 | Total Sales: 3952
Mckown
319 posts
Message posted at 11/11/2004, 22:27:15 PM by Mckown
The second shot is super, I especially like the lighting on the door!!
Nikon D300 , MB D10 Grip ,Nikon 18-55 VR Sigma 180 macro Ni...

Uploaded files: 625 | Total Sales: 2205
Pierdelune
153 posts
<10
Message posted at 11/16/2004, 11:14:58 AM by Pierdelune
It is really SUPER...
Nikon D300

Uploaded files: 1041 | Total Sales: 2044

Page:
1
  
 of 2
Showing posts 1 - 20 of 24
Current Server Time: 12/05/2009, 03:40:00 AM

 
Quicksearch :
  Upload image | About Us | FAQ | Contact Us | Terms of use | API / Referral program | Site map | Privacy policy
Support - phone: 1.615.771.5611, Click here to contact us

dreamstime
  Copyright © 2000-2009 Dreamstime. All rights reserved.
Dreamstime is a member of PACA and CEPIC.